Written 16th November 2026 by Matthew Claughton
The conviction and sentencing of Russell Brand has reopened an important debate about so-called “rape myths”, the way complainants are questioned in court and, ultimately, what constitutes a fair trial. In this feature, I want to discuss the concept of rape myths, but I also want to take a wider look at the system and give some consideration to the pre-charge stage of a case and the opportunities arising from improvements that have been made to investigations.
On 9th November, Brand was sentenced to 10 years and six months’ imprisonment after being convicted of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault. He had also been acquitted of two further rape charges and one count of attempted indecent assault.
Some of the strongest reaction has centred not on the verdicts themselves, but on the way parts of Brand’s defence were presented. And that raises a difficult question.
How do we ensure that outdated misconceptions about the behaviour of rape victims play no part in criminal trials, while preserving the fundamental right of an accused person to challenge the prosecution evidence robustly?
We should not pretend that there is an easy answer.
What are rape myths?
The expression “rape myths” describes assumptions about how a genuine victim of rape ought to have behaved.
They include assumptions such as:
- if someone was really raped, they would have screamed or shouted;
- they would have physically resisted;
- they would have tried to escape;
- they would have suffered obvious injuries;
- they would have reported the rape immediately;
- they would have told friends or family straight away;
- they would not subsequently have contacted the person accused;
- they would appear visibly traumatised or distressed;
- prior consensual sexual activity makes later consent more likely;
- somebody who has voluntarily become intoxicated bears some responsibility for what happened;
- meeting through a dating app, flirting, dressing in a particular way or previously discussing sex implies consent.
The Crown Prosecution Service RASSO (Rape and Serious Sexual Offences) guidance expressly addresses misconceptions and assumptions of this kind. Research commissioned by the CPS also found that public understanding remains far from complete. Among other things, there remains confusion about the absence of physical resistance, delayed reporting, the lack of physical violence and the way somebody might appear after an alleged assault.
There is an important principle behind all of this. There is no single way in which somebody who has been sexually assaulted will behave.
What happened in the Russell Brand trial?
Brand’s barrister, Ian Winter KC, attracted considerable criticism following his closing speech.
He reportedly invited the jury to consider that none of the complainants had “resisted or screamed or even tried to leave”. He also drew attention to delays in reporting and questioned why complainants had not come forward during the MeToo movement.
Claire Waxman and a possible change in the law
Victims’ Commissioner Claire Waxman has gone further and proposed legislative change.
Her concern is that “outdated and harmful assumptions” about how rape complainants behave can still influence trials. In particular, she highlights expectations that somebody who has genuinely been raped must have screamed, resisted their attacker or immediately reported what had happened.
Waxman wants a legal duty introduced requiring judges to direct juries about rape myths and misconceptions in every rape trial. Her argument is not that judges cannot do this already. They can. Her concern is that the present approach is discretionary and therefore risks inconsistency.
Indeed, the Crown Court Compendium, produced by the Judicial College, already contains guidance for judges on jury directions. The Ministry of Justice confirmed in the House of Lords on 9 November that judges already “can and do” give directions concerning rape myths, tailored to the circumstances of the individual case, and specifically identified the Compendium as the primary source of guidance.
This is where I have some sympathy with those who question whether legislation is necessary. There is a difference between providing judges with comprehensive guidance and requiring a particular direction irrespective of the issues arising in an individual trial. Because, Judicial discretion matters.
Sir Mark Rowley: “There isn’t one way of reacting”
Metropolitan Police Commissioner Sir Mark Rowley has strongly supported Waxman’s proposal.
Asked about the reported suggestion that none of Brand’s complainants had resisted, screamed or tried to leave, he said the approach came “very close to victim blaming”.
He made what I think is an important point:
“Some people will fight. Some people will freeze. Some people will tell people straight away. Some people bottle it up for years. There isn’t one way of reacting.”
He went further, arguing:
“It shouldn’t be possible for inaccurate statements to be made to a jury to suggest that because a rape victim didn’t behave in one way that somehow undermines their case.”
On the basic proposition, I agree with him. Human beings respond differently to traumatic situations. But there is a danger in taking the argument too far.
Dame Vera Baird KC: these are prejudices
The controversy has continued following sentence.
Speaking on Times Radio on the day following sentence, former Victims’ Commissioner and barrister Dame Vera Baird KC took a particularly strong position:
“Everybody knows that these are really myths and stereotypes, should be called prejudices because that’s what they are.”
She argued that barristers should not raise matters they know to be prejudicial simply in an attempt to be “a valiant hero for your defendant”.
Baroness Alison Levitt KC in a Law Society Gazette opinion piece of 12 November 2026 argued that best practice is not enough Sexual violence: best practice is not enough | Law Gazette. She has tabled an amendment to the Courts and Tribunals Bill that would require judges to give directions warning juries about harmful myths and stereotypes in certain cases, including rape.
So, we have seen powerful criticism. But as a defence solicitor of nearly 40 years’ standing, I think there is another side to the argument which must not be lost.
The defence must still be allowed to defend
A criminal trial is not simply an exercise in determining whether a complainant should be believed. The prosecution bears the burden of proving the defendant guilty so that the jury is sure.
That means evidence sometimes has to be challenged. Inconsistencies may need to be explored. Subsequent conduct may genuinely be relevant. Delay may sometimes have evidential significance. Communications before or after an alleged offence may matter enormously.
The fact that a question is uncomfortable does not necessarily make it improper. The difficult distinction is between challenging evidence because the circumstances of the particular case make it relevant and relying upon a stereotype about how a “real” victim ought to have behaved. Experienced defence practitioners understand that distinction.
At Olliers, our sexual offence specialists are acutely conscious of issues which may fall under the rape-myth umbrella. They need to be. But that can never mean failing to put forward a client’s defence properly and robustly.
The professional rules themselves recognise competing duties. The current Bar Standards Board Handbook makes clear that a barrister’s duty to act in the client’s best interests operates subject to duties of honesty, integrity, independence and duties to the court. Barristers must not knowingly or recklessly mislead the court, and contentions advanced must be properly arguable.
So robust advocacy and proper professional restraint are not opposites. Good advocacy requires both.
And the defence should not be prevented from exploring behaviour which may genuinely be relevant to the credibility or reliability of a complainant’s account. So, a failure to report an allegation immediately, should not of itself lead a jury to conclude that an allegation is untrue.
Timing of rape compaint
However, and this is the important bit, there will be times when the timing of a complaint and the circumstances surrounding a delay in reporting are relevant. The defence must be able to explore that evidence.
Let’s think of a very simple example. Consider a brief relationship where sexual activity takes place on a number of occasions overs several weeks. After a few weeks the relationship is abruptly ended by the defendant who leaves the complainant to for another woman. The complainant then alleges that the activity on the first night was non-consensual. The defence should be allowed to probe the timing of the complaint – without the jury feeling they should disregard the point because it comes within the category of a ‘rape myth’.
Anna Soubry: the safeguards are already there?
Former Conservative MP and practising barrister Anna Soubry has taken a different view from those expressed above. It’s one that I agree with. She has pointed out that judges already give firm directions to juries about misconceptions in rape cases, expressed disappointment at the Commissioner’s intervention and emphasised the importance of trusting both judges and juries. That deserves consideration.
The Crown Court Compendium exists. Judges can intervene. Judges can stop inappropriate questions. They can explain misconceptions to juries. They can tailor directions to the issues actually arising in the trial.
The question is therefore not whether safeguards exist. It is whether the existing safeguards are being used consistently enough.
Andy Burnham and the danger of measuring justice by convictions
Prime Minister Andy Burnham spoke at the beginning of the week. He said that rape trials must not leave a woman feeling that “she is on trial in court”. He has also said:
“We need to encourage more women to come forward to report rape. We need to get the conviction rate up. It has improved, but not enough.”
Asked about legislative change, he said:
“I wouldn’t rule anything out… I will study what’s happened here in great detail.”
Most people share a desire to increase confidence in the criminal justice system and to encourage people who have genuinely been subjected to sexual violence to report it. But surely the success of the criminal justice system should not be discussed primarily in terms of increasing numbers of prosecutions or convictions.
A prosecution is not, in itself, a successful outcome. Neither is a conviction simply because it increases a statistical conviction rate. The objective must surely be more fundamental – the right cases should be prosecuted, the wrong cases should be stopped, and those cases which reach court should be tried fairly.
Maybe Brand’s trial illustrates the point. The same jury which convicted him of four offences also acquitted him of three. That is the jury system doing something rather more sophisticated than simply choosing between believing or disbelieving all the allegations.
Not every allegation is true
This is an uncomfortable part of the debate, but it cannot simply be excluded. Not every complaint of rape or sexual assault ultimately proves to be true.
Some allegations arise from genuine mistake. Some accounts are unreliable. And, although deliberately false allegations must not themselves become another stereotype, malicious allegations do exist.
At Olliers we regularly act for people whose lives have been turned upside down by allegations which they emphatically deny. In some cases there is compelling material available at a very early stage which appears inconsistent with the allegation. In others there may be evidence supporting an identifiable motive to fabricate.
We have written previously about both the impact of false allegations and why false sexual allegations can happen.
Of course, this does not detract from the experiences of genuine victims. And, nor should acknowledging the existence of genuine victims require us to ignore the profound consequences for somebody who is wrongly accused. The criminal justice system has responsibilities to both.
Perhaps we should concentrate more attention pre-charge
This is where I think some of the present debate risks beginning at the wrong end of the process. Rather than concentrating exclusively upon how we increase prosecutions and convictions, I would like to see continued focus on getting cases right before anybody is charged.
In his 2015 review of criminal procedure, Review of Efficiency in Criminal Proceedings, Sir Brian Leveson placed considerable emphasis on “Getting it Right First Time”, case ownership and direct engagement between the parties. His review expressly considered charging decisions and the importance of effective work before cases reach trial. The Attorney General’s 2018 review of disclosure suggested ‘pre charge engagement’ between investigators and prosecutors and this was recognised in the 2020 Attorney Generals Guidelines on Disclosure.
For somebody under investigation for a serious sexual allegation, what happens before charge can be critical.
At Olliers we specialise in pre-charge representation. It is not simply about attending a police interview. Proper pre-charge work can mean identifying evidence the police have not considered, suggesting reasonable lines of enquiry, preserving digital or other material, obtaining material capable of undermining an allegation and making carefully prepared representations before the charging decision.
The objective is not to obstruct an investigation. It is to help ensure that the charging decision is the right decision.
Investigations – Operation Soteria may point towards the answer
Interestingly, there has already been a fundamental shift in the way rape investigations are approached.
Operation Soteria was introduced to transform rape and serious sexual offence investigations and has developed into a National Operating Model across all 43 Home Office police forces in England and Wales. It emphasises specialist investigation, evidence, suspect behaviour and proportionate lines of enquiry.
The Government has subsequently expanded Soteria principles into the courtroom. Its March 2026 announcement expressly described the approach as placing the suspect’s behaviour at the centre of a case while only seeking complainants’ private records where they are likely to have substantial probative value.
Our own work at Olliers reflects the other side of precisely the same principle. Our internal Operation Soteria material describes a suspect-focused, evidence-led investigation as potentially improving fairness for defendants too, because the investigation is concentrated upon what is genuinely probative rather than irrelevant or prejudicial material.
I have written in more detail about what Operation Soteria means for allegations of rape and serious sexual offences.
Where does the Russell Brand case leave us?
The Russell Brand trial has undoubtedly focused attention on the way rape cases are tried. Few would seriously argue that a complainant should be disbelieved simply because they did not scream, fight, flee or immediately report what happened.
Those assumptions can be dangerous. But it does not follow that the solution is to restrict legitimate cross-examination or make it more difficult for an innocent defendant to challenge an allegation.
Nor, in my view, should we judge the success of the criminal justice system by the number of people prosecuted or by driving conviction rates ever upwards. The system has to achieve something much harder.
It must encourage victims of sexual offending to have confidence to report what has happened. It must investigate those allegations professionally and sensitively. It must identify and eliminate irrelevant stereotypes. But it must also investigate evidence pointing away from guilt, recognise that not every allegation is reliable, allow the defence to challenge the prosecution case properly and protect the presumption of innocence.
Perhaps the answer is therefore less dramatic than some of the calls following the Brand trial suggest. We already have judicial directions. We already have professional rules governing advocates. We already have specialist RASSO prosecutors and increasingly specialist police teams. And through Operation Soteria, investigations themselves are becoming more focused and evidence led.
Perhaps what we need most is to make those existing protections work consistently. And, perhaps we should devote at least as much attention to the period before charge as we do to what happens in the courtroom afterwards.
Because the ultimate measure of a fair criminal justice system is not how many people it prosecutes. It is whether it prosecutes the right people, for the right offences, on the right evidence, and gives them a fair trial.
Manchester
Head Office
- 0161 8341515
- info@olliers.com
- Fourth Floor, 44 Peter Street, Manchester, M2 5GP
About the Author
Matthew Claughton·Managing Director
Olliers’ Managing Director Matthew Claughton is an outstanding criminal defence lawyer ranked by the Legal 500 2026 as a top tier practitioner in criminal law as well as the Northern Powerhouse Criminal Lawyer of the Year 2023. He has won the Manchester Legal Awards Partner of the Year twice.
More from Matthew
- Grooming Gang Investigations Reopened: Your Questions Answered
- What evidence can help defend a false sexual allegation?
- Defences to Possession of Indecent Images
- Law Commission Launches Major Consultation on Reform of Homicide Law (June 2026)
- What should I do if I am contacted by the police about a sexual offence?
